The long game of building wealth

Invest · Tax

Investing Outside an ISA: What the Tax Actually Costs

Once the £20,000 allowance is used, the next pound goes into a general investment account. Over 20 years the tax takes 19.8% of a higher-rate taxpayer's pot. Here is where.

The City of London skyline across the river in afternoon light

Most people never need this article: the £20,000 ISA allowance holds more than they will invest in a year. For those who do fill it, or who arrive with a lump sum larger than it, the next pound goes into a general investment account, taxed as you go. The tax is not ruinous, but it is real, it compounds against you, and most of it can be avoided with a little method.

The two taxes

Dividends. The first £500 a year is tax-free. Above that, dividends are taxed at 10.75% for a basic-rate taxpayer, 35.75% at higher rate and 39.35% at additional rate. A global tracker yields around 2%, so the allowance covers a holding of about £25,000; beyond that, every year's dividends carry a bill whether you spend them or not.

Capital gains. Nothing is due until you sell. When you do, the first £3,000 of gains in a tax year is exempt and the rest is taxed at 18% within your basic-rate band and 24% above it. The exempt amount was 12,300 four years ago; at £3,000 it is a far smaller shelter than it used to be.

What it costs over 20 years

Take £30,000 in a global fund, 2% yield and 5% growth, so 7% in total, held for 20 years with dividends reinvested after tax and the whole lot sold at the end. Inside an ISA it reaches £121,162.

Outside the ISAPot before saleGainCGT on saleKeptCost of being outside
Basic-rate taxpayer£117,208£63,404£10,873£106,335£14,827 (12.2%)
Higher-rate taxpayer£111,349£61,820£14,117£97,232£23,930 (19.8%)

The dividend tax along the way is small here, because £600 a year of dividends sits inside the £500 allowance until the pot has grown. The damage is the capital gains bill on the way out, and it is the one part of this that method can almost eliminate.

Outside an ISA the tax is not a rate, it is a habit. The people who pay most are the ones who never sell until they have to.

Four ways to cut it

  • Use the exempt amount every year. Selling enough to realise £3,000 of gains and buying back a similar fund resets your cost base for nothing. Over 20 years that is £60,000 of gains taken tax-free, worth £14,400 at 24%. You cannot buy back the identical fund within 30 days, but a different global tracker is fine.
  • Bed and ISA. Each April, sell from the general account and rebuy inside the new ISA allowance. The £30,000 here moves across in 1.5 years and the problem disappears.
  • Use a partner's allowances. Transfers between spouses and civil partners carry no tax, so a couple has two exempt amounts, two dividend allowances and possibly a lower tax band to sell in.
  • Prefer the pension for the long-term part. If the money is not needed before 57, a pension contribution gets relief going in and no tax on growth at all. Pension or ISA and carry forward for the large lump sum.

What to hold there

The same thing you would hold inside the ISA: one global tracker. An accumulating fund rolls dividends up for you, but they are still taxable as if paid, so keep the annual statement. Avoid income-focused funds in a taxable account, since they turn growth you could have deferred into dividends you must pay on now. The income trust question, worked through.

The dividend calculator shows the tax on a given dividend at your income. The AI Wealth Assistant will tell you whether a lump sum belongs in an ISA, a pension or a general account first.

C

Written by The Compound Desk
The Compound Desk is Compound Money's editorial team, led by an ACA-qualified chartered accountant with more than a decade in senior commercial finance roles. Everything we publish is checked against the current UK rules. More about Compound.

Free Guide

Get the free Compound Playbook

Every core tip from Compound distilled into one clear PDF. Enter your email and we will send it straight over.

Free PDF. By requesting it, you agree we can email you the guide plus occasional tips and offers. Unsubscribe anytime. See our Privacy Policy.