Every month a mortgage payment goes out and, if there is anything left, a question comes with it: put the spare money against the loan, or into a fund? People argue about this with real heat, which is odd, because it is mostly arithmetic, and the arithmetic has a clear answer once you know two numbers.
What each pound actually earns
Overpaying the mortgage earns exactly your mortgage rate, guaranteed, tax-free, for as long as the loan would otherwise have run. A pound off a 4.5% mortgage is a 4.5% return that no market can take away.
Investing earns whatever the market gives. Over long periods a broad global fund has returned around 7% a year before charges; our calculator assumes 7% less 0.5% of charges, so 6.5%. That is higher than most mortgage rates, and it is also not guaranteed in any given year, decade or lifetime. Why one global fund is the sensible default.
The gap, on real money
Take £200 a month for 20 years, so £48,000 of your own money either way.
- Invested at 6.5%: about £98,084.
- Overpaying a 4.5% mortgage, which is a guaranteed 4.5% return: about £77,625. The investor ends £20,459 ahead.
- Overpaying a 6% mortgage: about £92,408. The gap shrinks to £5,676, which is within the range a bad decade would erase.
So the honest summary is this. With a mortgage rate well below 6%, investing wins on expectation and the margin is real. As the mortgage rate approaches the return you expect from shares, the guaranteed option stops being the dull choice and starts being the good one. Both figures assume a fixed return and are illustrations rather than forecasts.
What overpaying does to the mortgage itself
The same £200 a month looks different from the other side of the ledger. On a £200,000 mortgage at 4.5% over 25 years, the normal payment is £1,112 a month and the total interest over the term is £133,499. Add £200 a month from the start and the loan clears in about 18.9 years, 6 years and 1 month early, with total interest of £97,219. The overpayments save £36,280 of interest.
That saving is real and it is guaranteed, and it is also exactly the 4.5% return counted above, arriving as interest you never pay rather than as growth you can see. It is not an extra benefit on top of the £77,625; it is the same money described differently. What overpaying does give you that a fund cannot is a date: the month the payment stops.
A mortgage overpayment is the only investment where you know the return to the decimal place before you make it. The question is whether that certainty is worth the gap.
The order that decides it for you
In practice the question rarely arrives on its own, and the things around it usually settle it.
- Expensive debt first. Anything on a card or an overdraft is a guaranteed return far above either option. The order to clear it.
- Then a cash buffer, because an overpayment cannot be withdrawn when the boiler fails. How big it should be.
- Then any pension match you are not taking. An employer match is an instant 50% or 100% that beats both the mortgage and the market. Why skipping it is turning down a pay rise.
- If you pay higher-rate tax, a pension contribution costs you 60p in the pound and a mortgage overpayment costs you a full pound. That alone usually decides it. Pension or ISA first.
Only after those does "overpay or invest" become a live choice, and by then it is usually about temperament rather than maths.
Two practical points
Most fixed-rate deals let you overpay up to 10% of the balance a year without a charge, and charge a percentage of the overpayment above that. Check your own terms before sending a lump sum; the penalty can wipe out years of the advantage.
And if you do invest, use the ISA allowance so the comparison stays fair. Outside a wrapper the 6.5% is taxed and the mortgage's 4.5% is not, which narrows the gap further than the figures above suggest. The bigger question, whether to own at all, is worked through separately.
Change the rate and the term in the compound growth calculator to see the gap at your own mortgage rate. The AI Wealth Assistant will tell you which rung of the order you are actually standing on.