The long game of building wealth

Save · Cash

Premium Bonds, Cash ISA or Easy Access: Where Should Your Cash Sit?

A 4.35% prize fund rate that nobody actually earns, a 4.5% account that is taxed, and an ISA that is neither. Which wins depends on your tax band and how much cash you hold.

A pile of plain white envelopes tied with string

Premium Bonds are the most popular savings product in Britain and the most misunderstood. The headline 4.35% is real, in the sense that NS&I pays that much of the total pot out in prizes each year. It is not what you will get. Here is how the three places most people keep cash actually compare once tax and probability are allowed for.

What the 4.35% means

The prize fund rate is the average return across every bond in issue. Because the prizes are skewed, two of £1m a month and a long tail of £25s, the typical holder earns less than the average and a few holders earn far more. With £20,000 of bonds you can expect about 11.4 prizes a year, almost all of them £25, and the mean is held up by jackpots you will not win. With £1,000 there is a 56% chance of winning nothing at all in a whole year, which is why small holdings are a lottery ticket rather than a savings account.

Two things the rate does give you: every prize is tax-free, and the money is backed by the Treasury with no £85,000 limit. The maximum holding is £50,000.

The comparison that matters: after tax

Interest on an ordinary account is taxed at your marginal rate once you have used your personal savings allowance, £1,000 for a basic-rate taxpayer, £500 at higher rate, nothing at additional rate. Take 4.5% easy access against the 4.35% prize fund rate and a cash ISA at 4.2%:

£20,000 heldInterest or expected prizesTaxKeptRate kept
Easy access, basic rate£900£0£9004.5%
Easy access, higher rate£900£160£7403.7%
Easy access, additional rate£900£405£4952.5%
Premium Bonds, expected£870nil£8704.35%
Cash ISA£840nil£8404.2%

At £20,000 a basic-rate taxpayer with the allowance intact keeps the whole £900 in easy access and should not bother with bonds. A higher-rate taxpayer keeps 3.7%, and the bonds' 4.35% expected return beats it, with the caveat that "expected" is doing real work in that sentence. An additional-rate taxpayer has no allowance at all and bonds or an ISA win outright.

At £50,000 the picture tilts further, because the interest blows through every allowance:

£50,000 heldInterest or expected prizesTaxKeptRate kept
Easy access, basic rate£2,250£250£2,0004.0%
Easy access, higher rate£2,250£700£1,5503.1%
Premium Bonds, expected£2,175nil£2,1754.35%
Cash ISA£2,100nil£2,1004.2%

The prize fund rate is an average, and averages of lotteries are earned by nobody in particular. Compare it with what you keep after tax, not with the rate on the poster.

How to decide

  • Basic-rate taxpayer, under the allowance: the best easy-access rate you can find, taxed at nothing, beats both. Bonds add variance for no expected gain.
  • Higher or additional rate, or interest over the allowance: fill the £20,000 cash ISA allowance first, because it is certain and tax-free. Bonds for cash beyond that, accepting the lumpiness, before taxable easy access.
  • Over £85,000 in one place: bonds carry a Treasury guarantee on the whole £50,000, which is the one feature no bank can match.
  • Money you might need next month: bonds take up to eight working days to cash and you miss the draw in between. Keep the first month of the emergency fund somewhere instant.

One date to plan around: from 6 April 2027 savings interest is taxed at 24%, 44% and 49% rather than 20%, 40% and 45%, so every taxed row above gets worse and the case for the ISA and for bonds gets stronger. The cash ISA limit stays at £20,000.

None of these rates are forecasts. The prize fund rate is variable and has moved several times in two years; the account rates are illustrative. The tax rules are the stable part. Where to park cash covers the fixed-rate and notice options this piece leaves out, and how the allowances change once your income is a pension.

Put your own balance, rate and salary into the savings interest tax calculator to see what you keep after tax; the prize fund rate is what to beat. The AI Wealth Assistant will tell you how much cash you should be holding at all.

C

Written by The Compound Desk
The Compound Desk is Compound Money's editorial team, led by an ACA-qualified chartered accountant with more than a decade in senior commercial finance roles. Everything we publish is checked against the current UK rules. More about Compound.

Free Guide

Get the free Compound Playbook

Every core tip from Compound distilled into one clear PDF. Enter your email and we will send it straight over.

Free PDF. By requesting it, you agree we can email you the guide plus occasional tips and offers. Unsubscribe anytime. See our Privacy Policy.