Everyone choosing a mortgage wants to know where interest rates are going. Nobody knows, including the people paid to, and the market's own guess is already in the price of every fixed-rate deal. So the useful question is a different one: if you guess wrong, what does it cost, and can you afford to be wrong? That turns a forecast into arithmetic.
The two products
A tracker follows Bank Rate, currently 3.75%, plus a fixed margin, so your payment moves whenever the Bank of England moves. A fix holds your rate for two, five or ten years whatever happens, and usually charges for the certainty: the longer the fix, the more you pay for it when rates are expected to fall, and the less when they are expected to rise. The Monetary Policy Committee next decides on 5 November 2026.
The arithmetic on a £250,000 loan
Take £250,000 over 25 years, with illustrative rates: a tracker at Bank Rate plus 0.5%, so 4.25%; a two-year fix at 4.35%; a five-year fix at 4.6%. The exact figures move weekly, the relationships between them do not.
| Product | Rate | Monthly payment |
|---|---|---|
| Tracker | 4.25% | £1,354 |
| Two-year fix | 4.35% | £1,368 |
| Five-year fix | 4.6% | £1,404 |
| Tracker if Bank Rate falls one point | 4.25% less 1% | £1,218 |
| Tracker if Bank Rate rises one point | 4.25% plus 1% | £1,498 |
The five-year fix costs £49 a month more than the tracker today, £594 a year. That is the premium for certainty. Each point Bank Rate moves changes the tracker payment by about £144 a month. So the fix pays for itself if Bank Rate averages more than about 4.1% over the five years, and loses if it averages less. Whether that is likely is the forecast nobody can make; whether a £144 a month rise would hurt is a question only you can answer, and it is the one that matters.
A fix is insurance. You do not buy insurance because you expect the house to burn down; you buy it because you could not afford it if it did.
Four questions that settle it
- Could you absorb two points? If Bank Rate went to 5.75% the tracker payment here would be about £1,649. If that number would mean missing other payments, the fix is not a bet, it is a necessity, whatever rates do.
- How long will you stay? Fixes carry early repayment charges, often several percent of the balance in the early years. Moving, separating or remortgaging inside the term can cost more than the rate saved. A tracker usually has none, and most allow unlimited overpayments.
- Is this your only exposure? Variable income, a partner between jobs or a business that suffers when rates rise all argue for fixing, because the mortgage would go wrong at the same moment everything else did.
- What is the gap today? When the fix costs only a few pounds more than the tracker, certainty is cheap and worth having. When the gap is £49 a month, you are paying real money for it, and the questions above decide whether it is worth paying.
What not to do
Do not pick a tracker because rates "will obviously fall", and do not pick a ten-year fix because they "will obviously rise". Both sentences have been said with total confidence before every move in the wrong direction for forty years. Do not fix for longer than you are confident of staying. And do not let the headline rate decide between two lenders: fees of £999 or more on a two-year deal are the equivalent of several tenths of a percent, and the comparison has to include them.
Whichever you choose, the decision that matters more over the life of the loan is whether to overpay it or invest the difference, and before that, whether to own at all.
The AI Wealth Assistant will place the mortgage in your order of priorities against the buffer, the debt and the pension. The compound growth calculator shows what the £49 a month premium would become if invested instead.