"Long-term investment plan" is a phrase that sells a lot of products. Most of them are the same two or three ingredients in different packaging. The one decision that actually matters is not which product but how long the money will be left alone, because that decides whether shares are sensible at all. Here is how to match the plan to the time.
Why the horizon decides everything
Take £200 a month, either in cash at 4% or in a global fund at 7% less 0.5% of charges. Both rates are fixed illustrations, not forecasts.
| Years | Paid in | Cash at 4% | Global fund at 6.5% | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3 | £7,200 | £7,636 | £7,926 | £290 |
| 5 | £12,000 | £13,260 | £14,135 | £875 |
| 10 | £24,000 | £29,450 | £33,681 | £4,231 |
| 25 | £60,000 | £102,826 | £149,767 | £46,941 |
Over three or five years the expected gain from investing is small. A single bad year wipes it out: a 20% fall just before you need the money leaves the five-year fund at £11,308, £1,952 behind the cash. Over 25 years the same fall at the end still leaves the fund £16,988 ahead. That asymmetry is the whole case for matching the plan to the horizon. Why time does the work.
Shares are not risky or safe. They are risky for money needed soon and close to the safest choice there is for money needed in twenty years.
The plan, by horizon
- Under five years: cash. An easy-access account, a fixed-rate bond or a cash ISA. The point is that the money is there on the day. Which kind of cash.
- Five to ten years: the honest grey zone. A mix of cash and a global fund, moving towards cash as the date approaches, is the usual answer. Do not put money you will definitely need in year six entirely in shares.
- Over ten years: a single low-cost global index fund, and then leave it. Why one fund is enough.
- Retirement: the longest horizon most people have, so the strongest case for shares, inside a pension for the tax relief.
The wrapper, in order
The wrapper matters more than the fund, because the tax it saves compounds alongside the return. For most people the order is:
- Workplace pension up to the employer match. No investment beats free money. Why skipping it is turning down a pay rise.
- Lifetime ISA if you are under 40 and saving for a first home. The rules.
- Stocks and shares ISA for anything you might want before 57.
- More pension for money you will not touch until retirement, especially as a higher-rate taxpayer. ISA or pension first.
- A general investment account only once the ISA is full. What that costs in tax.
What makes a plan work
The products are the easy part. What actually decides the outcome is a standing order the day after payday, a fund with charges in the tenths of a percent, and not selling in a bad year. Every one of those is free. The automation, and what a percentage point of fees does over 25 years.
Put your own monthly amount and years into the compound growth calculator. The AI Wealth Assistant will tell you which rung of the order you are on before you choose a product.