A student loan is called a loan, has a balance, and charges interest, so people treat it like a mortgage and want it gone. For many graduates that instinct is expensive. For some it is exactly right, and the two groups are not the ones you would guess. The loan is better understood as a time-limited tax, and the question is what you will hand over in total before the time runs out, with and without overpaying.
How repayment actually works
On Plan 2, for anyone who started an English or Welsh course between 2012 and 2023, you repay 9% of earnings above £29,385, taken through PAYE like tax. Interest runs between 4.1% and 6% depending on income. Whatever is left is written off 30 years after the April you were first due to repay. Plan 5, for courses from 2023, has a lower threshold of £25,000, interest of 4.1%, and a 40-year write-off.
The balance does not change what you pay each month. Only your salary does. Someone earning £40,000 pays £80 a month whether they owe £20,000 or £60,000. That is why the balance is the wrong thing to look at.
| Salary | Plan 2 repayment a month |
|---|---|
| £30,000 | £5 |
| £40,000 | £80 |
| £55,000 | £192 |
| £80,000 | £380 |
What three graduates actually repay
Take a typical Plan 2 balance of £45,000 at graduation, salaries rising 3% a year, and the interest rate that applies at each income. Simulated month by month to the write-off:
| Starting salary | Outcome | Total repaid |
|---|---|---|
| £32,000 | never clears, written off after 30 years | £57,678 |
| £45,000 | never clears, written off after 30 years | £113,341 |
| £70,000 | clears in about 14 years | £69,120 |
The middle row is the one to sit with. The £45,000 starter never clears the loan and still repays £113,341, two and a half times what they borrowed, because for the first decade the interest outruns the repayments and the balance grows. The £32,000 starter never clears it either, but pays far less, because the 9% never catches up with anything and the write-off does the work.
Now add £200 a month
- On £32,000: the loan clears in about 21 years, total paid £76,804, £19,126 more than letting it run, because the write-off was doing the work.
- On £45,000: the loan clears in about 14 years. Total paid, overpayments included, £66,745, which is £46,596 less than letting it run to the write-off.
- On £70,000: clears in about 9 years instead of 14, saving roughly £10,853.
So the popular rule, never overpay a loan that will be written off, is half right. It is right for the low earner, for whom forcing the loan to clear costs more than the write-off would have saved. It is badly wrong for the graduate in the middle, whose balance is compounding faster than they are paying it down. What decides it is the total you hand over, not whether the balance reaches zero: even £100 a month on the same £45,000 salary means the loan clears in about 20 years, total paid £79,969, £33,371 less than letting it run.
The graduate who never clears the loan can be the one who gains most from overpaying. The one who forces a small loan to clear can pay more than if they had left it alone.
The three tests
- Does the overpayment lower the total you repay? Run it with your own balance, salary and rate, to the write-off, both ways. If the total is higher with the overpayment, every extra pound is a gift to the Student Loans Company, and the monthly deduction, which is set by salary, does not fall by a penny in the meantime.
- Is the interest higher than the money would earn elsewhere? Plan 2 interest reaches 6% for higher earners, more than cash pays and close to what shares are expected to return. Plan 5, at 4.1% over 40 years, is a weaker case for overpaying and a stronger case for the write-off.
- Is there a pension contribution available first? For a higher-rate taxpayer, relief at 40% beats any of this, and it lowers the loan repayment as well. Pension or ISA first, and where a loan sits against the mortgage.
The lever most graduates miss
Repayments are 9% of gross pay above the threshold, and salary sacrifice reduces gross pay. Sacrificing £5,000 into a pension cuts the year's loan repayment by £450, on top of the tax and National Insurance it saves. For someone who will never clear the loan, that is a permanent saving rather than a deferral. How salary sacrifice works, and why the same logic applies to a bonus, which is also charged at 9%.
The take-home pay calculator includes the student loan deduction at your salary and plan. The AI Wealth Assistant will place the loan in your order of priorities, which for most graduates is nowhere near the top.