Plenty of people first meet the phrase on a payslip or a benefits portal: "salary exchange", sometimes "SMART pensions" or "pension exchange". It sounds like a separate product. It is not. It is the same arrangement as salary sacrifice, under a friendlier name, and it is usually the cheapest way you will ever pay into a pension.
What actually happens
You agree to a lower contractual salary, and your employer pays the difference straight into your pension. Because that money is never paid to you as salary, it is taken out before income tax and before National Insurance. Your payslip shows a lower gross pay, or a deduction labelled exchange or sacrifice above the tax line, and a larger employer pension contribution.
Compare the usual alternative. Under relief at source you pay in from take-home pay and the provider adds 20% tax relief, but you have already paid National Insurance on that money and nobody gives it back.
What a contribution really costs
| Salary | Exchanged into pension | Take-home falls by | Cost per £1 in the pot |
|---|---|---|---|
| £30,000 | £1,500 | £1,080 | 72p |
| £50,000 | £2,500 | £1,800 | 72p |
| £60,000 | £5,000 | £2,900 | 58p |
| £110,000 | £10,000 | £3,800 | 38p |
A basic-rate taxpayer puts a pound in the pension for 72p, against 80p under relief at source, because the National Insurance is saved too. A higher-rate taxpayer pays 58p. In the band between £100,000 and £125,140 the exchange also restores personal allowance, so each pound costs 38p. Why that band is the best place in the country to contribute.
Salary exchange is not a different pension. It is the same pension, paid for with money the tax and NI system never got to touch.
The employer's half of the saving
Your employer stops paying 15% employer National Insurance on the salary you exchange: £750 a year on a £5,000 exchange. Some keep it. Many pass part or all of it into your pension, which makes the arrangement better still. Ask what yours does, because it is the single biggest difference between one employer's scheme and another's.
What to check before you increase it
- Pay-linked benefits. Life cover, pay rises and sometimes the pension contribution itself may be calculated on the lower salary. Most good schemes use a "reference salary" to avoid this; check.
- Mortgage applications. Lenders see the lower salary. Say so when you apply.
- The minimum wage. Exchange cannot take pay below it, which limits the scheme for lower earners.
- Student loans. Repayments fall too, by 9% of the exchange. Whether that is a saving or a deferral for you.
The same mechanism can buy other things, but since 2017 almost everything except a pension, childcare support and an electric car loses the tax saving.
The salary sacrifice calculator is a salary exchange calculator under its other name: put in your salary and the amount to exchange to see the fall in take-home and the rise in the pot. The full guide is salary sacrifice, the higher earner's most underused move.